Hearsay Testimony in an Unemployment Hearing
testimony is testimony at the hearing, under oath, from someone who heard about what
happened from another person or who saw or heard an incident on tape after-the-fact.
Some states are prohibited by law from making a finding of fact based on only hearsay
evidence. Hearsay testimony is not as credible as first-hand testimony because the
person who actually witnessed what happened at the time is not testifying under oath
at the hearing and therefore cannot be questioned by the hearing officer.
If the claimant appears at the hearing and denies everything,
the claimant’s first-hand denial almost always outweighs hearsay testimony.
End result – the claimant probably wins.
Hearsay Evidence Includes:
Testimony about an interview of the people who saw what
Testimony about what was seen on video or heard on tape,
unless the tape itself is presented as evidence
A written statement by someone who does not appear to testify
Documentation created by someone who does not appear to
Testimony about a complaint made by a customer
Testimony by anyone who did not see what happened, but
who made a conclusion about the claimant’s activities based on what they saw or heard
we discussed before, hearing decisions often come down to a question of credibility
and greater weight will always be given to first-hand witness testimony. The hearing
officer needs to decide who is the most credible to make his findings of fact. He/she
uses the findings of fact to decide whether the facts support the claimant’s
eligibility for benefits in accordance with state law.
This weblog is sponsored by TALX.
Recommended For You
A violation of your organization’s drug-free policies can seem like an open and shut case, but is it? Monthly Video […]
A picture is worth a thousand words, but what if it’s a telephone hearing? Monthly Video Series: 5 of 12 […]
Case Analysis: Claimant was absent from the work area and found “resting” in locker room Background A company discharged its employee […]
Case Analysis: Claimant did not report her absences in order to have them covered by FMLA Background A company discharged […]